Gintsugi: Silver Kintsugi, and Why the Silver Turns Black

Two blue-and-white plates on teal cloth, the rim of the upper one filled in gold and the rim of the lower one filled in silver

Gintsugi is a repair in which a break or a chip is joined with lacquer and the seam is finished in silver powder.

Use gold and it is kintsugi; use silver and it is gintsugi. The only difference is the metal laid on at the end. Everything up to that point is the same.

The difference from kintsugi is the last step alone

Both are repaired with true lacquer. Join with lacquer, fill with lacquer, build the lacquer up in layers, then dust the metal powder on last. Every stage up to dusting the metal is shared.

What to compare Kintsugi Gintsugi
Joining and filling True lacquer True lacquer (the same)
Finishing powder Gold Silver
How it reads The line stands out clearly Close to white; settles into the piece
Change over time Almost none White, then grey, then black
Cost High Lower

Whatever the finish, the strength of the join does not change. What holds the piece together is the lacquer, not the metal on top of it. Choosing silver is not choosing a weaker repair.

Silver turns black. And it comes back.

This is where gintsugi is most often misunderstood.

Exposed to air and water, silver sulphides: it goes from white to grey and in time to black. The bright state a piece is in the day it comes back from repair does not last long.

That is not deterioration.

  • Polishing brings the shine back Blackened silver can be polished again. It returns to something close to its original white.
  • The silver alone can be re-laid If it will not come back, the silver can be dusted on again over the lacquer beneath, which is left as it is.
  • Some people prefer it darkened Silver that has settled to black is described as having quietened. As with a piece that grows, it is received as a piece that has taken time into it.

Choose it knowing it will change. That is what living with gintsugi means. Keinen bika applies to a repaired line as much as to the piece itself.

The range of finishes

Gold and silver are not the only ways to finish a join.

Finish Character
Gold The brightest, and the line reads most clearly. Also the most expensive
Silver Closest to white. Quietens as time passes
Platinum Nearer grey. Unlike silver, it does not tarnish
Tin Coarser particles; a slight roughness stays under the finger
Coloured lacquer No metal at all; finished in black roiro or red-brown iron-oxide lacquer

Platinum if you do not want it to change, coloured lacquer if you do not want the line to show at all. Silver sits between the two, and holds both brightness and quiet for longer than either.

What gintsugi suits

  • White pieces On white porcelain or kohiki, silver floats far less than gold.
  • Blue and grey glazes On cool-toned glazes such as celadon or ash glaze, the white of silver sits naturally.
  • Pieces in daily use It costs less than gold, which suits a repair meant to keep a piece in service rather than on a shelf.
  • When you do not want the repair to lead Kintsugi is a repair that shows the break. Gintsugi is quieter about it.

Living with a repaired piece

Every joined piece comes with the same conditions.

  • No dishwasher, no microwave Gold or silver on top, the layer underneath is lacquer. Heat and detergent damage it.
  • Wash by hand, with something soft Abrasive cleaners and metal scourers take the dusted metal off.
  • Do not leave it soaking Silver darkens faster in water. Dry it as soon as it is washed.

Handling the piece itself is covered in caring for Japanese ceramics, and for clay bodies in caring for stoneware.

Related reading

The idea of joining

Before you have anything repaired

Pieces silver suits

Pieces available at Nokaze

Pieces worth repairing

Nokaze ships pieces made one at a time by Japanese makers, direct from the region they come from. Every piece carries its maker's name, so you can trace who made it.

Browse bowls

FAQ

What is gintsugi?
Gintsugi is a repair in which a break or a chip is joined with lacquer and the seam is finished in silver powder. Finish in gold and it is kintsugi; finish in silver and it is gintsugi. Only the metal laid on at the end differs. Everything up to that point is the same.
What is the difference between kintsugi and gintsugi?
The last step alone. Both are joined with true lacquer, filled with lacquer, built up in layers of lacquer, and dusted with metal powder at the end. Whether that powder is gold or silver is the whole difference; every stage before it is shared.
Why does the silver in gintsugi turn black?
Because silver reacts with sulphur in the air and turns to silver sulphide. This is not damage but a property of the metal itself, and there is a way of seeing it in which the slow turn towards black is part of what the repair has to offer.

Shop the related pieces

New to Japanese pottery? Start here — its history, how pottery differs from porcelain, the clays and glazes behind each style, and how to care for a piece. → Japanese Pottery: The Complete Guide

Meet the Artisans

Delivery fee

From our Kyoto warehouse to the world. Shipping is a flat rate by region.

HK$50

Free shipping on orders over HK$1,500

Other additional taxesNo additional charge

No, there isn't.

No customs duties or sales taxes are levied on imported ceramics. You will not pay anything other than the displayed price.

NT$450

Free shipping on orders over NT$5,990

Other additional taxesPayment on arrivalDDU

Customs duties and business tax

It is not included in the price of the product. You will pay it directly to the delivery company or customs upon delivery. The amount varies depending on each country's system.

We don't currently ship to countries and regions not listed above. If you would like to purchase, please contact us.

View Delivery Policy

Contact Us

Please feel free to contact us regarding our services,
partnership, or orders. We look forward to hearing from you.

Contact Us

Meet the artisans behind the pottery

One artisan's story at a time, with the pieces they make, sent from our shop in Kyoto. Join today and get 5% off your first order.

Emails from Nokaze, Kyoto. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.